| Player | | | | Week 5 Picks | | |
| thebighkane | | | | | SF | . | MIN | . | LV | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | NE | . | JAX | . |
| (53) (9-5) 64.3% | |
| aj2024 | | | | | SF | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | JAX | . |
| (51) (9-5) 64.3% | |
| madskilz | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | LV | . | NYG | . | NYJ | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | HOU | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | NE | . | JAX | . |
| (59) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| ej1960 | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (52) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| derbypicks (h) | | | | | LAR | . | CLE | . | IND | . | NO | . | NYJ | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | CIN | . | WAS | . | NE | . | JAX | . |
| (45) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| coolest_picker_dude | | | | | SF | . | CLE | . | LV | . | NYG | . | NYJ | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | CIN | . | WAS | . | NE | . | JAX | . |
| (44) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| vdotross | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (44) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| daboyz | | | | | SF | . | CLE | . | LV | . | NYG | . | NYJ | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | CIN | . | WAS | . | NE | . | JAX | . |
| (41) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| markdun | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (41) (8-6) 57.1% | |
| butchh | | | | | SF | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (54) (7-7) 50% | |
| pttp88 | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | NE | . | KC | . |
| (53) (7-7) 50% | |
| markwill89 | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | CIN | . | LAC | . | NE | . | KC | . |
| (50) (7-7) 50% | |
| kanejim | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | JAX | . |
| (50) (7-7) 50% | |
| younggunz | | | | | SF | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (48) (7-7) 50% | |
| waltluv1 | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | DEN | . | MIA | . | HOU | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | WAS | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (38) (7-7) 50% | |
| bigkelt | | | | | SF | . | CLE | . | IND | . | NYG | . | NYJ | . | DEN | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | TB | . | CIN | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (55) (6-8) 42.9% | |
| mbosse | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | HOU | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (49) (6-8) 42.9% | |
| lla7365 | | | | | * | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (47) (6-7) 46.2% | |
| best_picker_dude | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | HOU | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (44) (6-8) 42.9% | |
| jeanne | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | CAR | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (13) (6-8) 42.9% | |
| whatupdoe | | | | | * | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NO | . | NYJ | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | JAX | . |
| (52) (5-8) 38.5% | |
| headhunter | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | LV | . | NO | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (37) (5-9) 35.7% | |
| jflex336 | | | | | LAR | . | MIN | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | SEA | . | DET | . | WAS | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (33) (5-9) 35.7% | |
| transformer | | | | | SF | . | CLE | . | LV | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | TEN | . | SEA | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (48) (4-10) 28.6% | |
| blackeye1827 | | | | | * | . | * | . | IND | . | NYG | . | DAL | . | PHI | . | MIA | . | BAL | . | ARI | . | TB | . | DET | . | LAC | . | BUF | . | KC | . |
| (38) (4-8) 33.3% | |
| | | | | | |